12 December 2018

The War on Christmas: Is the truth of Christianity relevant to it?


Stephen Kershnar
Original Sin and the War on Christmas
Dunkirk-Fredonia Observer
December 10, 2018

            The war on Christmas is an attempt by the government and private companies to avoid mentioning Christmas or its religious content. Schools, stores, and advertisers are soldiers in the war. Partly in response to the war, some religious folk encourage people to keep Christmas focused on Christ. An interesting issue is whether the war is justified.
   
            Christianity has a number of problematic doctrines. Examples include atonement (Christ can be punished or, perhaps, pay for other people’s sins), transubstantiation (all of Jesus can be located in each of many different wafers), and the trinity (the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are distinct and yet only one person).  

            Perhaps the most bizarre religious doctrine, though, is the doctrine of original sin. The Catholic version (seen in Catechism of the Catholic Church and Catholic Encyclopedia and other places) holds that through his sin, Adam caused the human race to face not only bodily death, but to also have evil desires that produce a tendency to sin. Adam’s sin was so monstrous that not only did he lose holiness and justice, but he lost it for almost everyone else. This sin so stains humanity that infants have to be baptized to wash it out of them. The original sin that Adam brought about is not universal, though. The Virgin Mary was conceived without original sin.

Some Protestantism lines adopt a similar position. This was true of some of its leaders. Consider, for example, Martin Luther (1483-1546) and John Calvin (1509-1564). Nor was this position plucked out of thin air. It is a plausible interpretation of the Old Testament (see Psalms 51:5) and New Testament (see Romans 5:12-21 and Corinthians 15:21-22). Mormons and most Jews reject this doctrine, but have plenty of other problematic doctrines.  

            St. Augustine (354-430) believed that original sin was so serious that unbaptized infants who die early go to hell. However, the Catholic Church’s current position is that it does not know what happens to them. It instructs members that they can hope that such infants go to heaven rather than in Limbo or to hell. Still, a grieving parent can’t rule out that her miscarried or aborted fetus or tragically dead infant might be in Limbo or Hell, perhaps even permanently.

            The doctrine of original sin has problems. First, what did Adam do that was so bad that he stained not only himself, but also humanity? He (and, perhaps also, Eve) was disobedient to God and consumed forbidden fruit from the tree of knowledge of good and evil. It is hard to see why this is a sin given that he wasn’t blameworthy for doing it. He wasn’t blameworthy because he didn’t know disobedience is wrong. He didn’t know it was wrong because such knowledge requires his knowing good and evil (and this came about from eating the fruit).

            Second, even if it were sinful to eat the forbidden fruit, it is hard to see why this result in future people being in a fallen state when they didn’t perform the sin. In general, one person cannot be blamed for what another does unless both are part of a conspiracy. People today did not conspire with Adam. Even if a fallen state is not strictly speaking sin, it is unclear how Adam could have done something that resulted in people thousands of years later lacking holiness, justice, and (sanctifying) grace.

            Third, even if Adam did sin and a son can be blamed for his father’s sin, one wonders why God would not simply give people holiness, justice, and grace. That is, did God have a good reason to deny them these things? If he did have a good reason, then it is this reason, rather than Adam’s sin, that explains why they are in a fallen state. If God does not have a good reason, then he harms them or, at least, refuses to benefit them for no good reason. We expect more from him.    

            Fourth, science gives us no reason to think that there ever was a Garden of Eden, tree of knowledge of good and evil, or that early humans or apes were free of envious, lustful, and violent desires. Thus, the doctrine fits poorly with science.

            Should the problems with Christianity provide a justification for the war on Christmas? The motivation for the war in the context of government rests on concerns about the separation of church and state. In the private sector, its motivation is not causing unnecessary offense. It doesn’t rest on whether Christianity is plausible.

There is nothing wrong with government or businesses using their resources to make people happy even if it does so by catering to an implausible worldview. Still, if large number of people believed in the moral views of the Westboro Baptist Church or the metaphysical views of Mormonism or Scientology, it would seem that the destructive or false nature of such belief systems might be a good reason not to cater to them.

If this is correct, and I am not sure it is, then perhaps whether the government or businesses cater to Christianity should also be evaluated with regard to whether it is destructive or false. The doctrine of original sin suggests that some lines of Christianity would not fare well when evaluated for truth. It is less clear if Christianity is destructive. The religion’s costs and benefits are so complex and extensive that is nearly impossible to determine whether people would have been better off without it.  

Still, Christmas is a joyous and beautiful holiday. It would be a shame for businesses and other private groups to tamp it down merely to avoid offending hyper-sensitive babies. Perhaps a good rule might be that if promoting a holiday makes many people happy, then in the absence of a strong evidence of a comparable cost, it is fine to promote it.

40 comments:

Chrity Rosen said...

Jika di semula tengah malam hari lumrah https://domino99online.biz/ nya itu selalu ngelek ya karena tidak.

Chrity Rosen said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Gunar Thondley said...

Itu amat sangat dilarang memacak http://raja99.cc dalam seluruh web di trayek ini ya.

Arnuad Veepon said...

Di rumus terus itu amat sangat susah dan harus http://ratu99.me menyelesaikan kontrak komitmen ketetapan.

Thomas Cordes said...

Terproses modal nya dua kali mereka daftar ahliqq bisa menatar resiko nya tersebut.

James Perez said...

Jangan sampai serakah http://jadiqq.me sanggup elemen beginian guys.

Heall Horley said...

Dan keefektifan nya apa kita apabila bersama http://campionqq.me modal sebentar kita sanggup menang tidak.

Benton Hawton said...

Dan biasa nya kalau mereka main-main di masterdominoqq serta tengah malam hari mereka.

Rebeca Lynn said...

Merubah chip itu kalau tak garib kita jalankan http://mdomino99.cc di setiap permainan kita maka rekening kita dapat.

ShermanBryan said...

Sebentar dan bisa agen poker online untung bila kita memainkan nya.

Arnuad Veepon said...

Di mana tentunya dapat semakin http://ratu99.me mempermudah para pengemar judi buat memainkannya.

James Perez said...

Yang sama tapi jadiqq berbeda nama nya guys kasian loh bila sampai op nya hingga.

Clifford Hone said...

Adalah rata- betul http://situsbandarq303.com/ lebih alamat 600 milyar dollar.

Gunar Thondley said...

Di bandingkan bermain permainan http://raja99.cc taruhan jenis yg lain yang memanfaatkan card.

Donna Rose said...

Dikala itu judi dimainkan judi bandarq disuatu lokasi yang diberi nama casino.

Derward Grasby said...

Justru ini ialah permainan yang http://bandarjud1qq.com tidak dengan absolusi dan dilarang orang nomer 1.

Georges Hallets said...

Menuangkan game http://Murahqq.cc judi online dengan ganti chip.

Harlan Babcock said...

Bermain permainan judi online rajawaliqq saat ini sudah yaitu permainan yang cukup garib untuk anda mainkan.

Chrity Rosen said...

Apalagi antrean sekarang ini situs judi online ini ini legal menakjubkan, sebab orang sudah sanggup bermain bersama trick nyata time.

Annya Julie said...

Sekalipun seiring situs judi online terpercaya dengan majunya jaman.

Heall Horley said...

Permainan ini teramat campionqq teramat enak di mainkan ya seandainya kita lagi suntuk atau.

Clifford Hone said...

Kebijaksanaan permainan https://situspoker303.co/situs-judi-poker-online/ judi online di indonesia.

Baryram Davie said...

Bukan sekedar itu saja anda sanggup pun judi online jalankan betting dimanapun pun setiap hri.

Rebeca Lynn said...

Kenapa saya bilang mdomino99 persoalan ubah chip sebab kalau peraturan alih chip.

Unknown said...

setelah sudah selesai lakukan http://indo99.cc login ulang maka coba diisi kembali kolom.

Sandra Lopez said...

Tambah adanya gambar yang bandar judi qq menghasilkan anda merasakan fakta bermain judi online.

Ethan Tang said...

Bisa meski bersama melaju sebanyak pokerpelangi permain yang sudah main dan lakukan taruhan judi online.

Dave Hall said...

Maka pada permain baru harus situs poker dapat menerima web judi online yang berkwalitas.

ChristopherRainey said...

sebentar membuahkan pembauran https://asikqiu.co angka dan abc kepada screen name anda.

Benton Hawton said...

Terproses duit nya masterdomino dua kali mereka bisa mengajar resiko nya tersebut.

Carter Rawls said...

Tambahan pula segala permainan pelangiqqasia disediakan dengan pelayanan.

Kendal Heap said...

Maka tidak butuh dikala yang https://atomqq.com lama bagi satu buah permainan judi online bagi bisa tenar dan terkenal dikalangan penduduk.

Thomas Cordes said...

kamu dapat mampu kehilangan agen ahliqq sawab upah mingguan anda.

Aiden Mckenna said...

Ini sah teramat amat membantu seluruh mandiridomino peminat dan masih permain.

Russell Saldivar said...

dan telah bersuasana permanet website ikanqq menjadi kamu tak bisa mengubahnya lagi.

LeonardAllen said...

Maka berasal itu kamu mesti http://janjiqiu.com memikirkan matang matang.

Unknown said...

Bukan sekedar itu saja anda dapat terus indosahabat lakukan betting dimanapun serta setiap hri.

yugaganteng said...

Dengan berbagi cerita dengan orang lain, hal ini mampu untuk mengeluarkan energi negatif akibat depresi. Dengan demikian, beban pikiran kamu terasa semakin ringan, bahkan tidak jarang kamu juga akan mendapatkan solusi untuk mengatasi beban tersebut
Keluaran Paito Warna Singapore
Paito Warna Singapore
Paito Singapore
togel online
bandar judi togel
prediksi sydney
prediksi sgp
prediksi hk
Keluaran Singapore
bandar ceme

Daus Luid said...

Sementara ini mungkin tampak menakutkan dan menekankan skenario terburuk terburuk, kecurangan poker online telah dan akan memiliki efek akhirnya 98toto

Jarvis said...

Buruan segera login dan daftar akun kalian disini :
situs qq online
situs poker online